If your Case 1840 or 1845C skid steer loader is running hot, a radiator replacement is on your to-do list. Two aftermarket radiators are aimed at these loaders, and while both claim fitment for the same Case models, their listed prices sit $195.00 apart. The lower-priced unit is the 1347609C1 1A12192 radiator; the higher-priced unit is the Skid Steer Loader Radiator from Eagle Cooling. Before you order, it pays to look at how each listing is presented and what part numbers they cross-reference, because a radiator is only useful if it matches the unit you are pulling out. Both products target the same loader models, but the condition labels and the amount of part-number detail differ, and that is exactly where your decision should start.
Quick verdict
If your priority is keeping the cost low, the 1347609C1 1A12192 radiator is the easy choice thanks to the lower listed price. If you prefer a radiator presented as a direct replacement with a named brand, the Eagle Cooling radiator is the one to lean toward. Both list fitment for the Case 1840 and 1845C, so the decision narrows down to what those differences are worth to you. Both listings stick to fitment, condition, and part-number details without additional performance promises, so treat the two as comparable in fitment but different in presentation and price.
Comparison
Here is how the two listings stack up side by side.
| Attribute | 1347609C1 1A12192 Radiator | Eagle Cooling Radiator |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 219.99 | USD 414.99 |
| Price bar | ||
| Listed condition | New other (see details) | New |
| Fitment | Case 1840 1845C skid steer loader | Case 1840 1845C skid steer loader; Case IH |
Where each product wins
The 1347609C1 1A12192 radiator wins on listed price and the described 3-row core, giving budget-focused shoppers a clear reason to choose it.
The Eagle Cooling radiator wins on direct-replacement fitment language and a named brand, which may matter if you prefer a clearly labeled aftermarket unit.
Product notes
1347609C1 1A12192 Radiator for Case 1840 1845C Skid Steer Loader
At USD 219.99, this is the more economical option. The listing describes a 3-row core radiator and carries part numbers 1347609C1, 1A12192, 301877A2, A173415, 301877A1, A173886, and 252930A1. If you are matching a used part number on an existing radiator, that kind of cross-reference is a practical benefit. The catch is the condition label: "New other (see details)." That wording is less definitive than the condition shown on the other listing, which is the main thing to weigh if you want a listing with no condition qualifiers.
Skid Steer Loader Radiator Fits Case 1840 1845C OEM# 1347609C1 1A12192 301877A2
Listed at USD 414.99, the Eagle Cooling radiator is a New-condition unit described as a direct replacement. It pairs OEM numbers 1347609C1, 1A12192, and 301877A2 with interchange number 1A18278, giving you a clear cross-reference path if you are verifying compatibility. The named brand and direct-replacement wording are the main draws here. The limitation is the higher listed price compared with the alternative. That naming clarity, plus the New status, is what separates it from the lower-priced listing. It is a simpler, cleaner listing for someone who prefers a straightforward replacement part.
Final choice by use case
Choose the 1347609C1 1A12192 radiator when spending less matters most. Choose the Eagle Cooling radiator when its listing details, including the direct-replacement fitment, are worth the additional cost.
